Friday, 18 May 2012
Name:

Email address:


Thursday, 17 March 2011

Stricken Fukushima power plant insurance cover minimal, sources say

By Herbert Fromme, Cologne
Email Author

As radiation from the endangered Fukushima nuclear power plant continues to rise and the exclusion zone around the plant expands, owner Tepco has no property insurance in place and third-party liability insurance that does not respond to earthquakes or tsunamis, sources say.


Fukushima nuclear power plant has suffered a series of problems since the March 11 earthquake and subsequent tsunami

Meanwhile claims experts have said they are unable to gain direct access to the stricken areas of Japan. This is only likely to add to the total costs of claims arising from the recent catastrophic events, they add.

Tepco has not bought any property insurance cover for its power stations since September 2010, German reinsurance sources said. Instead, it opted to pay for damages itself, following the example of companies such as BP that recently had to meet the cost of the Deepwater Horizon oil spill.

Tepco owns two of the three nuclear plants that are currently in danger of being destroyed by uncontrolled nuclear processes. The company has compulsory third party liability insurance of $1.5bn, but that is not triggered if earthquakes or tsunamis are the cause of an accident. The main part of the damage will have to be borne by the Japanese government.

Tepco already had to deal with significant quake damage at a nuclear power station in 2007. The Kashiwazaki-Kariwa power station was switched off for 21 months following serious damage in the wake of a magnitude 6.8 earthquake.

 

Please sign up here to our full-time mailing list to ensure that you receive our weekly newsletter.

Meanwhile, insurers with high exposure in Japan are finding it difficult to implement their usual catastrophe claims practices. “We have banned all travel to Japan,” said Andreas Shell, who is global head of claims (short-tail) for Allianz Global Corporate and Specialty (AGCS) and claims crisis manager for the full Allianz Group.

Mr Shell dealt with claims in the aftermath of the terrorist attack on the World Trade Centre in 2001 and following hurricane Katrina in 2005. “However, this is a totally different scenario,” he said. For the first time ever, the insurance giant is not in a position to send claims specialists to the affected area following a major catastrophe. This could lead to even higher claims because, as a rule, the later an insurer arrives on the scene, the more expensive business interruption claims become.

“In business interruption, the clock is ticking," said Mr Shell. “It is a fact that the later we become active, the higher the claims caused by business interruption.” Allianz and its clients cannot jointly implement any loss reduction measures, as is normally the case.

So far the insurer has received very few claims so it is too early to venture estimates about its total loss. “Our customers are not thinking about insurance at the moment but about their staff,” added Mr Shell.

Mr Shell said that the company would not approach clients with offers of settlements. "We do not know yet what losses we and the clients are talking about," he said. "Such an approach might give them the feeling that we do not want to give them what is due to them. Of course, we make interim payments on covered claims."

He added that European industrial companies who will suffer from a lack of parts due to temporary closures of Japanese suppliers might be insured for business interruption. "We then have a case of contingent business interruption," said Mr Shell. "The condition is that there has been an insurable event at the foreign supplier and production has stopped, and that contingent business interruption risk in Europe has been included in the policy," he said.

Japanese manufacturers are important producers of electronic components and other expensive parts needed by European industry. These parts are not easily replaced. There are fears among European companies that a prolonged shut-down of key suppliers will cause major problems.

Please sign up here to our full-time mailing list to ensure that you receive our weekly newsletter.

Commercial Risk Europe News Feed